Ingredients
Menopause supplement ingredients, graded by the evidence
Every active ingredient in the products we rank, plus the ones you see in reviews, with a plain-language grade and every study we used.
Last updated
Short answer: No ingredient earns an A for menopause symptoms. Soy isoflavones (B-) have the most consistent, if modest, data for hot flashes; calcium with vitamin D (B) supports bone health*; most branded botanicals are graded C (limited, often industry-linked trials), and several popular additions such as DIM, evening primrose oil and omega-3 are graded D.
| Studied for | Menopause Society 2023 | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Vitamin D & calcium | B | bone health after menopause | Not part of VMS statement. | 6 |
| Collagen peptides | B- | skin hydration/elasticity | Not assessed. | 0 |
| Soy isoflavones & genistein | B- | hot flashes | Not recommended (Level II) – mixed evidence. | 6 |
| Red clover | C+ | hot flashes | Not specifically named (supplements not recommended). | 3 |
| St John's wort + black cohosh | C+ | menopausal symptoms with mood component | Black cohosh not recommended; combination noted as possibly augmented. | 1 |
| Ammonium succinate (Amberen) | C | menopausal symptoms | Not recommended (Level II) – limited, manufacturer-sponsored. | 2 |
| Ashwagandha | C | menopausal symptoms, sleep, stress | Not assessed. | 5 |
| Black cohosh | C | hot flashes / menopausal symptoms | Not recommended (Level I) – 'insufficient evidence to support use for VMS'. | 5 |
| ERr 731 rhapontic rhubarb | C | perimenopausal symptoms | Not recommended (Level II) – placebo-arm retention only 12.7% in key RCT; open-label study. | 3 |
| EstroG-100 | C | menopausal symptoms incl. hot flashes | Not specifically assessed (falls under 'supplements/herbal remedies – not recommended'). | 2 |
| Fenugreek | C | menopausal symptoms | Not assessed. | 0 |
| Flower pollen extract | C | hot flashes | Not recommended (Level III). | 2 |
| Hyaluronic acid (oral) | C | skin hydration | Not assessed. | 0 |
| Pycnogenol (pine bark) | C | climacteric symptoms | Not assessed. | 2 |
| S-equol | C | hot flashes, muscle/joint aches | Not recommended (Level II) – mixed evidence. | 1 |
| Saffron (affron) | C | mood during perimenopause; hot flashes | Not assessed. | 1 |
| Sage | C | hot flashes/sweating | Not assessed. | 1 |
| Hops (8-PN) | C- | menopausal symptoms | Not assessed. | 2 |
| Maca | C- | menopausal symptoms, mood, libido | Not recommended (Level II). | 1 |
| Probiotics | C- | menopausal symptoms; bone | L. acidophilus YT1 not recommended (Level II). | 3 |
| Vitex (chasteberry) | C- | menopausal symptoms | Not recommended (Level II). | 4 |
| DIM | D | estrogen 'balance' | Not assessed. | 2 |
| Evening primrose oil | D | hot flashes | Not recommended (Level II). | 1 |
| Magnesium | D | hot flashes; sleep | Not assessed. | 3 |
| Omega-3 (fish oil) | D | hot flashes, mood | Not recommended (Level III) – mixed. | 0 |
| Pueraria mirifica | D | menopausal symptoms, vaginal dryness | Not assessed. | 0 |
| Rhodiola | D | menopausal symptoms | Not assessed. | 0 |
- B
Vitamin D & calcium
Calcium and vitamin D support bone health*. Large trials, including the Women's Health Initiative, show a small effect on bone density, and effects on fractures are mixed.
4 studies · in 6 ranked products
- B-
Collagen peptides
Collagen peptides support skin hydration and elasticity*, based on about ten small trials, many of them industry-funded.
2 studies · in 0 ranked products
- B-
Soy isoflavones & genistein
Soy isoflavones (including genistein) are the most widely studied supplement group for occasional hot flashes associated with menopause*. Meta-analyses find modest average effects, such as about 20% fewer hot flashes than placebo in one analysis, and results vary between trials.
6 studies · in 6 ranked products
- C+
Red clover
Red clover isoflavones have been studied for occasional hot flashes*. Some meta-analyses report short-term effects, but a 12-month NIH-funded trial and a Cochrane review found no clear benefit over placebo.
5 studies · in 3 ranked products
- C+
St John's wort + black cohosh
A fixed combination of black cohosh and St John's wort has been studied for occasional mood changes associated with menopause*. St John's wort interacts with many common medicines.
3 studies · in 1 ranked product
- C
Ammonium succinate (Amberen)
Amberen's ammonium-succinate blend has been studied for common menopause symptoms* in two placebo-controlled trials and one open-label study, all linked to the manufacturer. The amount of each component is not disclosed.
4 studies · in 2 ranked products
- C
Ashwagandha
Ashwagandha root extract has been studied for occasional stress, sleep quality and common symptoms in perimenopause and menopause* in a few small placebo-controlled trials, all run in India.
3 studies · in 5 ranked products
- C
Black cohosh
Black cohosh is the most-studied herb for occasional hot flashes and night sweats associated with menopause*. Independent trials and a Cochrane review found no clear benefit over placebo, other reviews found a small one, and rare liver-injury reports exist.
14 studies · in 5 ranked products
- C
ERr 731 rhapontic rhubarb
ERr 731 is a rhapontic rhubarb root extract (the active in Estroven Complete) studied in perimenopausal women for occasional hot flashes and related symptoms*. The placebo-controlled trials come from one research group.
4 studies · in 3 ranked products
- C
EstroG-100
EstroG-100 is a Korean three-herb blend studied for occasional hot flashes and other common menopause symptoms* in three small placebo-controlled trials. The EU food-safety authority (EFSA) judged it safe only up to 175 mg a day, below the 514 mg a day used in most products.
4 studies · in 2 ranked products
- C
Fenugreek
Fenugreek seed extract has been studied for occasional hot flashes and night sweats* in a few placebo-controlled trials, mostly linked to ingredient makers.
2 studies · in 0 ranked products
- C
Flower pollen extract
Purified flower-pollen extract (the active in Relizen) is a non-hormonal ingredient studied for occasional hot flashes and night sweats*. Only two small placebo-controlled trials exist, and pooled controlled data were not statistically significant.
3 studies · in 2 ranked products
- C
Hyaluronic acid (oral)
Oral hyaluronic acid supports skin hydration*, based on a few small trials.
2 studies · in 0 ranked products
- C
Pycnogenol (pine bark)
Pycnogenol, a French maritime pine bark extract, has been studied in three controlled trials for occasional hot flashes and sleep problems in perimenopause*.
2 studies · in 2 ranked products
- C
S-equol
S-equol is a soy-derived compound (the active in Equelle) studied for occasional hot flashes and muscle aches associated with menopause*. Results are mixed, and the key trials were sponsored by companies behind the ingredient or product.
3 studies · in 1 ranked product
- C
Saffron (affron)
Saffron extract has been studied for occasional low mood and feelings of anxiousness in perimenopause*. In the largest menopause trial it did not reduce hot flashes.
2 studies · in 1 ranked product
- C
Sage
Sage has traditionally been used for occasional sweating and hot flashes*. A 2023 meta-analysis of four trials found no significant effect on how often hot flashes happen.
3 studies · in 1 ranked product
- C-
Hops (8-PN)
Hop extract, a source of the potent plant estrogen 8-prenylnaringenin (8-PN), has been studied in a few small trials for occasional hot flashes*, with mixed results.
3 studies · in 2 ranked products
- C-
Maca
Maca is an Andean root food studied in a few small trials for mood and libido during menopause*. The trials were too few and too small to be conclusive.
2 studies · in 1 ranked product
- C-
Probiotics
Probiotics support digestive health*. Only one strain (L. acidophilus YT1) has a menopause-symptom trial, and it is not in any product we ranked; effects on bone are mixed.
3 studies · in 3 ranked products
- C-
Vitex (chasteberry)
Vitex (chasteberry) has better evidence for menstrual-cycle comfort than for menopause. The largest menopause trial (100 women, combined with St John's wort) found no benefit over placebo.
2 studies · in 4 ranked products
- D
DIM
DIM (3,3'-diindolylmethane) changes how the body breaks down estrogen. Its effect on menopause symptoms has not been tested in a single clinical trial.
1 studies · in 2 ranked products
- D
Evening primrose oil
Evening primrose oil has not been shown to reduce how often hot flashes happen; trials found at most a small effect on how severe they feel.
3 studies · in 1 ranked product
- D
Magnesium
Magnesium supports normal muscle and nerve function*. In the one large menopause trial (289 women), it did not reduce hot flashes compared with placebo.
1 studies · in 3 ranked products
- D
Omega-3 (fish oil)
Omega-3 fish oil did not reduce hot flashes, sleep problems or mood symptoms compared with placebo in the largest independent trial (MsFLASH, 355 women).
2 studies · in 0 ranked products
- D
Pueraria mirifica
Pueraria mirifica contains strong plant estrogens. Evidence is limited and low quality, and safety concerns have been reported in Japan. None of the products we ranked contains it.
2 studies · in 0 ranked products
- D
Rhodiola
Rhodiola has been studied for menopause in only one trial, in combination with black cohosh, by an author with ties to the seller.
1 studies · in 0 ranked products
*These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. These products are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease. Solynes does not sell supplements; descriptions summarize published research and are not medical advice.