Ingredients

Menopause supplement ingredients, graded by the evidence

Every active ingredient in the products we rank, plus the ones you see in reviews, with a plain-language grade and every study we used.

Last updated

Short answer: No ingredient earns an A for menopause symptoms. Soy isoflavones (B-) have the most consistent, if modest, data for hot flashes; calcium with vitamin D (B) supports bone health*; most branded botanicals are graded C (limited, often industry-linked trials), and several popular additions such as DIM, evening primrose oil and omega-3 are graded D.

All 27 ingredients. Select a heading to sort.
Studied forMenopause Society 2023
Vitamin D & calciumBbone health after menopauseNot part of VMS statement.6
Collagen peptidesB-skin hydration/elasticityNot assessed.0
Soy isoflavones & genisteinB-hot flashesNot recommended (Level II) – mixed evidence.6
Red cloverC+hot flashesNot specifically named (supplements not recommended).3
St John's wort + black cohoshC+menopausal symptoms with mood componentBlack cohosh not recommended; combination noted as possibly augmented.1
Ammonium succinate (Amberen)Cmenopausal symptomsNot recommended (Level II) – limited, manufacturer-sponsored.2
AshwagandhaCmenopausal symptoms, sleep, stressNot assessed.5
Black cohoshChot flashes / menopausal symptomsNot recommended (Level I) – 'insufficient evidence to support use for VMS'.5
ERr 731 rhapontic rhubarbCperimenopausal symptomsNot recommended (Level II) – placebo-arm retention only 12.7% in key RCT; open-label study.3
EstroG-100Cmenopausal symptoms incl. hot flashesNot specifically assessed (falls under 'supplements/herbal remedies – not recommended').2
FenugreekCmenopausal symptomsNot assessed.0
Flower pollen extractChot flashesNot recommended (Level III).2
Hyaluronic acid (oral)Cskin hydrationNot assessed.0
Pycnogenol (pine bark)Cclimacteric symptomsNot assessed.2
S-equolChot flashes, muscle/joint achesNot recommended (Level II) – mixed evidence.1
Saffron (affron)Cmood during perimenopause; hot flashesNot assessed.1
SageChot flashes/sweatingNot assessed.1
Hops (8-PN)C-menopausal symptomsNot assessed.2
MacaC-menopausal symptoms, mood, libidoNot recommended (Level II).1
ProbioticsC-menopausal symptoms; boneL. acidophilus YT1 not recommended (Level II).3
Vitex (chasteberry)C-menopausal symptomsNot recommended (Level II).4
DIMDestrogen 'balance'Not assessed.2
Evening primrose oilDhot flashesNot recommended (Level II).1
MagnesiumDhot flashes; sleepNot assessed.3
Omega-3 (fish oil)Dhot flashes, moodNot recommended (Level III) – mixed.0
Pueraria mirificaDmenopausal symptoms, vaginal drynessNot assessed.0
RhodiolaDmenopausal symptomsNot assessed.0

*These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. These products are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease. Solynes does not sell supplements; descriptions summarize published research and are not medical advice.