Guide · Ingredient
Black cohosh: what the studies show, liver safety and adulteration
Black cohosh evidence for hot flashes, the liver-injury reports, how often products are adulterated, and which ranked products contain it at what dose.
Last updated · By the Solynes editorial team · Methodology
Short answer: Black cohosh is the most-studied herb for occasional hot flashes and night sweats associated with menopause*. Independent trials and a Cochrane review found no clear benefit over placebo, other reviews found a small one, and rare liver-injury reports exist. The Menopause Society (2023) does not recommend it (Level I). Quality is a real problem: a 2024 review found 42.2% of 322 tested black cohosh samples were adulterated or mislabeled, mostly with Asian Actaea species.
Does black cohosh help with hot flashes?
It depends on which studies you weigh. The independent Cochrane review (Leach 2012: 16 trials, 2,027 women) found no difference from placebo in hot-flash frequency. Large publicly funded US trials were also null: HALT (351 women, 12 months), Geller 2009 and Pockaj 2006. A 2023 meta-analysis (Sadahiro 2023) found a small-to-moderate benefit, and a 2026 International Menopause Society review rated the evidence moderate certainty (Maunder 2026). The most positive pooled results for the Remifemin extract come from a review co-authored by the manufacturer's staff (Castelo-Branco 2021).
Evidence grade: C C (iCR extract specifically: C+). See all 14 studies.
Liver safety
Rare liver injury reports (USP: 30 cases 'possible' causality; ODS: ≥83 cases worldwide, causality unproven). USP-recommended label: discontinue if liver disorder or symptoms of liver trouble. No evidence of increased breast-cancer risk (Fritz 2014), but safety after breast cancer not established (NCCIH). Possible interaction with statins (NCCIH).
A US Pharmacopeia expert review of 30 liver cases rated all of them “possible” (none probable or certain) and recommended a cautionary label (Mahady 2008). A manufacturer-written pooled analysis of five iCR trials found no effect on liver enzymes (Naser 2011). The practical takeaway from the USP: stop and see a clinician if you notice symptoms of liver trouble, such as dark urine, yellowing skin or eyes, or abdominal pain, and talk to your clinician before use if you have liver disease.
Adulteration: is it really black cohosh?
- Systematic review (Natural Product Reports 2024): 42.2% of 322 black cohosh samples across 78 publications adulterated/mislabeled, mainly with Asian Actaea species. pubs.rsc.org
- DNA barcoding (J AOAC 2012): 9 of 36 (25%) US black cohosh supplements matched Asian Actaea. pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
- Jiang et al. 2006: 3 of 11 products contained Asian Actaea instead of black cohosh. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
- LiverTox: >50 cases of clinically apparent liver injury linked to products labeled black cohosh; USP monograph requires liver-caution statement. ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
None of the black cohosh products we ranked is listed in NSF's public registry. Remifemin uses a named, standardized extract (iCR) and is sold as a registered herbal medicinal product in Germany, according to its maker.
Ranked products with black cohosh
| Product | Black cohosh per day | $/day | Score |
|---|---|---|---|
| Remifemin Menopause Relief | Black cohosh extract (iCR) 40 mg | $0.50 | 61.8 |
| Estroven Menopause Relief + Weight Management | Black cohosh root extract 40 mg | $0.63 | 58.4 |
| Nature's Way Black Cohosh Premium Extract | Black cohosh root/rhizome extract, standardized 2.5% triterpene glycosides 80 mg | $0.42 | 51.5 |
| O Positiv MENO Menopause Gummies | Black cohosh root extract 40 mg | $1.40 | 50.8 |
| Gaia Herbs Menopause Support Daytime | Organic black cohosh root extract 600 mg | $1.53 | 40.2 |
Most trials used about 40 mg a day of extract. Gaia's 600 mg is a whole-root extract amount and is not directly comparable to standardized extract doses.
Black cohosh and breast cancer
A systematic review found no evidence that black cohosh raises breast-cancer risk, and no proven hot-flash benefit in breast-cancer patients (Fritz 2014). NCCIH says its safety after breast cancer has not been established. If you have had breast cancer, talk to your oncology team before taking it.
FAQ
Is black cohosh bad for your liver?
Rare cases of liver injury have been reported in people taking products labeled black cohosh; causality is unproven, and the US Pharmacopeia recommends a liver-caution label. Talk to a clinician before use if you have liver disease, and stop if you notice signs of liver trouble.
How much black cohosh was used in studies?
Most trials used about 40 mg a day of extract (for example, Remifemin's iCR extract at 20 mg twice daily). The Cochrane review reported a median of 40 mg a day for about 23 weeks.
More guides
- Do menopause supplements work? What the trials actually showNov 19, 2026
- Estroven vs Amberen vs Relizen vs Remifemin: an evidence-based comparisonNov 19, 2026
- Menopause supplements with NSF certification, checked against the registryNov 19, 2026
- Menopause supplements for hot flashes, sleep and mood: what's been studied for eachNov 19, 2026
- Soy isoflavones and breast cancer: what's known (and what isn't)Nov 19, 2026
*These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. These products are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease. Solynes does not sell supplements; descriptions summarize published research and are not medical advice.